#TwitterBan: Exploring the legal intricacies of Nigeria’s decision

by | Jun 7, 2021

It is no longer news that the Nigerian government has indefinitely banned Twitter’s operations in the country.

This was disclosed by the Minister of Information and Culture, Lai Mohammed, on Friday, June 4, 2021. He also revealed the government’s directive to the National Broadcasting Commission (NBC) to begin the process of licensing over-the-top (OTT) and social media platforms.

Since then, we’ve seen the Nigerian Communications Commission (NCC) instruct telcos to suspend access to Twitter.

WhatsApp Image 2021 06 05 at 11.40.13 AM

In another statement released on Saturday, June 5, 2021, Garba Shehu, the President’s Senior Special Assistant on Media and Publicity, cited the platform’s role in disseminating false information and fake news as the rationale behind the ban.

Advertisement

He also advised disregarding the notion that the ban is a knee-jerk reaction to the deletion of a tweet made by the Nigerian President, Muhammadu Buhari.

The tweet in question, which referred to the Nigerian Civil War, was removed by Twitter for violating its policy on referencing mass murders, violent events, or specific means of violence where protected groups have been the targets or victims.

This is not the first time the government has attempted Internet censorship. It had gone the expected legislative route in 2019 with the “social media bill”, which was outrightly rejected by Nigerians. 

The bill is officially titled “Protection from Internet Falsehoods and Manipulations and Other Related Matters Bill 2019” and prescribes a ₦300,000 ($730) fine or a jail term of up to three years for persons spreading false information or that which could affect the nation’s security and relationship with other countries.

Because it was perceived to be a gag on citizen’s right to freedom of expression as enshrined in the Constitution, it received a lot of backlash from the Nigerian public. As of press time, the bill has not progressed further than the second reading stage.

So far, discussions on Techpoint Africa have focused on the economic impact, a possible Internet firewall, and security issues arising from the use of VPN. However, this discourse will analyse the legal issues surrounding the government’s decision.

Our chat with three lawyers — Co-founder, Tech-Hive Advisory, Ridwan Oloyede; Lead Advisor, Lawrathon, Enyioma Madubuike; and Tech Lawyer and Policy Consultant, Timi Olagunju, — is detailed below.

Is the ban legal?

All three lawyers agree that the ban is illegal. 

Advertisement

According to Oloyede, the ban is “an attack and suppression of the freedom of expression guaranteed under the Constitution and other international human right norms that Nigeria is a party to.”

This right to freedom of expression as contained in Section 39 of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1999 (as amended) provides for freedom to hold an opinion and to receive and impart ideas and information without interference. 

A 2016 United Nations (UN) resolution on the promotion, protection, and enjoyment of human rights on the Internet guarantees the protection of human rights — particularly, freedom of expression — offline and online. A resolution confirmed by Oloyede to have been supported by Nigeria.

Other international treaties which expressly provide for this right include the African Declaration on Internet Rights and Freedom, the UN Universal Declaration of Human Rights, and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, all of which Nigeria is a party to.

To put all of this in context, the Constitution is regarded as the “grundnorm” of all laws in Nigeria. The law from which all other laws, policies, regulations, and guidelines draw their legality. If any of these in any way deviate from the spirit of the Constitution, it cannot stand. 

As Olagunju puts it, these international treaties/conventions are meant to promote rather than restrict this right. The only condition for restriction is where it is expressly provided for by law or as a matter of national security, public order, or the reputation of others. This is also contained in Section 45 of the Constitution.

According to Oloyede, the conditions for derogating from human rights under the constitution were not met.

“An executive decision cannot be considered a law reasonably justified in a democratic society. As we speak, there is no legislation from the National Assembly prohibiting the use.”

As Madubuike puts it, “There are processes provided for actions that would impact citizens’ rights; this unilateral action has been done without any due process. None.”

Other aspects to consider under this heading involve the declaration made by the Attorney General of the Federation (AGF) and Minister of Justice, Abubakar Malami, which effectively orders the prosecution of anyone found using Twitter.

Nigerian law clearly states that no one can be prosecuted for a crime that is unknown to law.  

According to Madubuike, “Tweeting is not a crime. The fact that a minister says otherwise does not make it so. Crimes are created by specific laws made by lawmakers, not by declaration of a Minister. We are still a constitutional democracy despite all appearances otherwise.”

NBC, Ministry of Information and Culture, and its powers

The NBC, by virtue of its establishing Act, has regulatory powers in respect of broadcasting. This means that its purview is in relation to television and radio companies. This places the Commission under the aegis of the Ministry of Information and Culture, headed by Mohammed.

Therefore, in the context of Mohammed’s proclamation, it seems he may have overstepped his bounds

Olagunju attributes the powers exercised by the MInister as likely being under the umbrella of the National Information Technology Development Agency (NITDA) as an agency with an Information and Communication Technology (ICT) framework under the purview of the Ministry for Communication and Digital Economy.

He also says that the directive regarding OTT and social media licences might be a back door to enacting the social media bill, which must be looked at in light of the National Assembly’s oversight powers in that regard.

Other legal issues which have been raised include the use of videos and pictures gotten from Twitter as evidence in court. Both Oloyede and Olagunju agree that the Evidence Act of Nigeria is more concerned with the relevance of the evidence rather than its source.

Thus, a defense of a Twitter ban in such a scenario would not suffice.

What we may have to worry about is the Judiciary’s role and independence. Ordinarily, Nigeria practises the doctrine of separation of powers which, as Oloyede explains, means the Executive, Judiciary, and Legislature are independent bodies.

Several organisations such as the Socio-Economic Rights and Accountability Project (SERAP) and the Nigerian Bar Association (NBA) have made known their intentions to contend the legality of the ban in court.

While we know the ban is illegal, it is now up to the courts to give a decision.

Looking to transition into tech? Learn how to code in 1 year with AltSchool Africa. Earn a diploma in software engineering at $0. Apply Here.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
1 Comment
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Emnellykas
Emnellykas
6 months ago

Nigeria and her misplaced priorities

Recent News

Betting $165 million on Africa’s B2B eCommerce in 2021

Betting $165 million on Africa’s B2B eCommerce in 2021

While Africa’s eCommerce struggles frequently make the news, investors have bet a combined $165 million on a growing class of startups in 2021. Today on #TechpointDigest, @eruskkii discusses the rise of B2B marketplaces in Africa.

Subscribe to Techpoint Digest!

A daily 5-minute roundup of happenings in African and global tech, sent directly to your email inbox, between 5 a.m. and 7 a.m (WAT) every week day!

Please check your email to confirm your subscription.

Subscribe to Crypto Explorer

A monthly series featuring in-depth analysis on the cryptocurrency sector in Africa

Please check your email to confirm your subscription.

Subscribe to The Experts

A bi-weekly where tech career specialists take us on their journey from newbie to expert, and how they became successful in the industry.

Please check your email to confirm your subscription.

Subscribe to Founder's Table

A monthly series, where we catch up with founders in the startup ecosystem, learn about their failures, successes and a few tricks of the trade

Please check your email to confirm your subscription.

Copy link
Powered by Social Snap