The scapegoating of MTN Nigeria, Senator Dino Melaye and the capital flight epidemic

by | Sep 29, 2016

MTN Nigeria may still be one foot into hot water with the legislative arm of the Nigerian government. There are indications that the telecommunications group may still be probed further by the Nigerian Senate.

The telco has been in tussles with the Nigerian Communications Commission (NCC) over the hefty fine imposed on the by the commission. After agreement was reached to pay a reduced fine, MTN Nigeria appeared to be faring well with the proposed launch of its 4G LTE services.

During a sitting of the Nigerian senate, Dino Melaye a senator representing the Kogi West Senatorial District moved a motion to probe the telecom giant for allegedly repatriating $12 billion dollars to South Africa over the past 10 years.

Advertisement

According to a report in the Punch Newspapers, Senator Dino said,

“My respected colleagues, MTN Nigeria paid a sum of $284.9m on the 6th of February, 2001 to purchase their licence of operations in this country. Between 2006 and 2016, through four Nigerian banks and a serving minister of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, MTN moved over $12bn out of Nigeria.  That is about half of our external reserves. If I get the nod of the Senate, I will want to bring a substantive motion on the next legislative day with substantiated facts to buttress this position.”

Still based on the report, the Senate proceeded to ask Senator Dino to present substantive evidence at the next sitting of the senate.

The myriad of complexities involved with the fines associated with failure to comply with directives of the NCC might elicit a “serves-you-right” nod from everybody.

And maybe it does serve them right as this would act as a deterrent of sorts to multinationals who deem it fit to flout laws and directive.

If you ever wonder why MTN has to be the scapegoat, think back to secondary school days when one person had to be punished to make every member of the class behave.

Scapegoating is an age long practice and its necessity and effectiveness cannot be undermined. In a very similar government versus multinational case, in 2012 the USA’s House of Representative warned American companies in a 60-page document against using equipment manufactured by Huawei and ZTE.

Advertisement

They cited security concerns and backdoor operations as what the companies were complicit in. These accusations have been controversial, but the scapegoating had been done and dusted,

But it becomes uncomfortable when it is assumed that every one has learnt their lessons and the scapegoat is still suffering.

Still slightly recovering from the NCC fight, the Copyright Society of Nigeria (COSON) hit with a ₦16 billion lawsuit for copyright infringement on Caller Ring Back Tunes and music used on MTN Nigeria’s platform in general.

And now here is Senator Dino Melaye’s impending capital flight probe that I have a deep-seated feeling would see the light of day.

Capital flight has always been a thing

According to the Concise Encyclopedia of Economics,

There is no widely accepted definition of capital flight. The classic use of the term is to describe widespread currency speculation, especially when it leads to cross-border movements of private funds that are large enough to affect national financial markets.

Africa, with numerous natural and human resources, has always been susceptible to capital flight since time immemorial.

Capital-Flight-Africa

Image Credit; Community Monitors

Apparently, the epidemic is hurting the African economy as it only makes sense that when there are more withdrawals than additions, there is bound to be a tilt in the equality scale.

Concentrating on Nigeria, the Niger Delta regions with its plenteous oil reserves would have been a tourist mecca like Dubai if the giant mosquito of capital flight had not drained it.

Mentioning corporations alone in the context of this epidemic would be partial. Politicians and billionaires that make money in Nigeria and buy real estate abroad, those that buy jets and pay for their services and maintenance outside the country are also complicit.

The Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) stated that $22.1 billion went out of the country in the first five weeks of Q1 2015. The point to note is that capital flight did not start with MTN Nigeria and may not end with them if not properly checked on a grand scale.

How the cookie crumbled

On the 21st of September 2015, Chief Olu Falae was kidnapped. The Ondo State born politician, who was former Secretary to the Government and Federal Minister of Finance in the 1990s during the military regime of Ibrahim Babangida, was taken from his farm days before his 77th birthday.

Chief Olu-Falae Photo; Vanguard

Chief Olu-Falae
Photo; Vanguard

During the period, the abductors allegedly made a call asking for a ₦100 million ransom. Security operatives swung into action demanding for their details, but MTN Nigeria was reportedly unable to produce registration data for the numbers used to make the calls because the SIMs were not yet registered.

This was coming after an August deadline the NCC had given telcos to disconnect all unregistered mobile lines.

Rumors have swirled that ingredients in the pot of pepper soup MTN Nigeria is in were the aftermath of Chief Olu Falae’s kidnap. The conspiratorial nature of this claim makes it hard to believe, but facts are hard to ignore

 MTN Nigeria must pay. And everybody else too

The case against MTN Nigeria is seemingly watertight as unscrupulous violation of the Foreign Exchange and Miscellaneous Act was cited.

For failing to obtain a Certificate of Capital Importation(CCI) when they were incorporated, the capital repatriation by MTN is illegal under the aforementioned act.

During that last plenary, Senator Dino Melaye made some shocking and bone chilling revelations as regards capital repatriation and tax evasions. In his words,

Only God knows if they [MTN Nigeria]  even paid tax

Many influential and powerful members of the Nigerian society were indicted on charges of facilitating the capital repatriation. Even serving government officials too.

This is not the first time MTN Nigeria is being scrutinised. In 2015, an investigation by the Premium Times revealed a messy tax evasion scheme and mum was the word until now.

It is estimated that Nigeria loses an upwards of $8 billion annually in the oil and gas industry and nothing is been done to stymie this corruption.

Witch hunt or not, MTN Nigeria should be prosecuted if found guilty, and while they are at it somebody should also “Dino Melaye” the oil companies too. And all the politicians and multinationals in Nigeria.

On the other hand, Senator Dino Melaye was the initiator of the Remita probe that has dealt a visible blow to government and private software development partnership. But again, if this probe is sustainable then we may just act like Remita didn’t happen.


Suggested Read: Nigeria’s Senate probes TSA and terminates Remita’s contract


The Nigerian government can make more watertight policies and laws and enforce them. Like the maritime industry where the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) issued a directive to Nigerian banks to always confirm the reasons behind request for foreign exchange or freight component of their international transactions. This simple act alone has reportedly prevented $3 billion in capital flight from Nigeria.

Featured Image: 10b travelling via Compfight cc

Victor Ekwealor
Victor Ekwealor

tech. media. startups. africa. vc | Twitter: @victor_ekwealor

On January 22, 2022, be part of the largest gathering of innovators, startup founders, thinkers, programmers, policymakers, and investors in West Africa. Register free.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
2 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Oladele Mayungbe
Oladele Mayungbe
5 years ago

hmmmmmmmmmmmmm this is Nigeria 70% of the matter happens under the table, as for Mtn launching of its 4G LTE services will happen, more so me and you will celebrate it either ship or expensive rate, remember in 2015 MTN Nigeria in mega deal to sell 9,151 towers to IHS, they were far ready for this business, forecasting in management is working i must tell you Mtn gat bills to pay, and again the matter of tax paying, Until companies stop buying fuel and diesel for business till than we will surly see transparency in tax paying my brother

persius VPN
persius VPN
5 years ago

The issue of capital flight is one that is quite sensitive to every nation. Every investor puts money in economies where there is liquidity flow and investment friendly. NCC and the Nigerian government should simply revisit every trade agreement it enters into with investors. This should be done in a way that it doesn’t discourage financial inflows and innovation capacity.
The TSA issue with Remita is a good reminder in the sense that this was a 100% wholly local company. Why wasn’t the issue of capital flight raised, but instead the senate went ahead to raise a motion investigate this local company.
Our government should be careful with the way it percieves any form of investment as this will not only frusrate investors locally and abroad but wil adversely affect local innovations especially in the creative industry like the ICT sector.

Recent News

Subscribe to Techpoint Digest!

A daily 5-minute roundup of happenings in African and global tech, sent directly to your email inbox, between 5 a.m. and 7 a.m (WAT) every week day!

Please check your email to confirm your subscription.

Subscribe to Crypto Explorer

A monthly series featuring in-depth analysis on the cryptocurrency sector in Africa

Please check your email to confirm your subscription.

Subscribe to The Experts

A bi-weekly where tech career specialists take us on their journey from newbie to expert, and how they became successful in the industry.

Please check your email to confirm your subscription.

Subscribe to Founder's Table

A monthly series, where we catch up with founders in the startup ecosystem, learn about their failures, successes and a few tricks of the trade

Please check your email to confirm your subscription.

Copy link
Powered by Social Snap